How NIH plans to fight the sexual harassment that could drive women away from science


JUDY WOODRUFF: In this era of MeToo revelations,
it is increasingly clear the fields of science, engineering and medicine also have more to
do when it comes to stopping or reducing sexual harassment and discrimination. A milestone report found between 20 percent
to 50 percent of female students in those fields experienced harassment, often from
faculty and staff. More than 50 percent of faculty said they
too experienced harassment. That report added new pressure on the National
Institutes of Health, one of the biggest funders of scientific research in the U.S. Today, the head of the NIH joined William
Brangham for a conversation. It’s part of our weekly science segment, the
Leading Edge. WILLIAM BRANGHAM: Last year’s report documented
an all-too-common story: Existing anti-harassment policies at different scientific institutions
simply didn’t do enough to stop the problem, and there was too little accountability to
help those who come forward. Now the director of the NIH, Dr. Francis Collins,
has issued a frank apology for not doing more. Dr. Collins wrote — quote — “We are sorry
that it has taken so long to acknowledge and address the climate and culture that has caused
such harm. Sexual harassment in the sciences, he wrote,
is — quote — “morally indefensible, it’s unacceptable, and it presents a major obstacle
that is keeping women from achieving their rightful place in science.” And Dr. Francis Collins joins me now. Welcome back to the “NewsHour.” DR. FRANCIS COLLINS, Director, National Institutes
of Health: Thanks. Great to be with you, William. WILLIAM BRANGHAM: I guess, in the MeToo era,
it should be no surprise that these problems would plague the sciences as well. But the numbers that Judy cited about the
number of women in these fields who claim they have been a victim of some of these crimes
is still very striking. Why do you think it is so bad in the sciences? DR. FRANCIS COLLINS: I think the sciences, like
many other fields where this has been most prominent, are male-dominated, traditionally. That’s changing, but not changing quickly
enough. Most of the senior leadership in academic
institution tends to be male. And that kind of culture then encourages this
willingness for what can sometimes be more subtle forms of gender harassment, but sometimes
also provides the kind of environment where other sexual coercion activities may happen. We need to change that. And that’s one of the messages from that National
Academy report. WILLIAM BRANGHAM: In male-dominated fields
— and we have seen this in the military in other ways where women have moved in — is
it partly because women are moving into more traditionally male-dominated fields? Or is it simply that the men are — just don’t
appreciate that they can’t act the way they have been acting? What’s the dynamic there? DR. FRANCIS COLLINS: In science, women are a significant
part of our work force. But, still, we have not achieved the point
where women have their rightful place in leadership. If you go to the top tier of organizations
that are doing science in universities, they are disproportionately male. Yet graduate students, post-docs, medical
students, we’re at pretty close to 50/50 in those categories. But why is there such a problem in seeing
that kind of advance happen? Clearly, this is an environment that is not
always welcoming to women. One of the reasons we’re so concerned about
sexual harassment is, it does create a climate that discourages talented women from continuing
on that pathway towards senior leadership. And we’re losing that talent. And that’s bad for everybody. WILLIAM BRANGHAM: Yes, that certainly seems
like one of the — not only is there an emotional and psychic toll to being the victim of this
kind of thing. DR. FRANCIS COLLINS: Yes. WILLIAM BRANGHAM: But it also deprives science
of half the population, if they view this as a field that is not open to them. DR. FRANCIS COLLINS: Absolutely. And there’s enormous talent there that we
are, therefore, deprived of. And we’re discouraging people who have visions
of what they might be able to contribute who encounter this unpleasant and somewhat constrictive
atmosphere with sexual commentary that is demeaning and degrading. And they sort of say to themselves, I don’t
know if this feels like a place I want to spend my career, and go off and do something
else. We lose a lot of women at that point of going
from being a trainee to becoming an independent faculty person. WILLIAM BRANGHAM: Let’s talk a little bit
about the issue of accountability, because that is such an enormous part of this, that,
if you are in a culture where this kind of behavior is going on, so many women that I
have heard from and that have been reported in this field say, I just didn’t feel like
I could go to anyone and that the behavior would ever stop. How do we address that? Because if you can’t report it, and feel like
you’re going to get some sense of justice, you either endure it or you get out. DR. FRANCIS COLLINS: And that’s what NIH and,
for myself, as the director, we’re trying to change now. We have been perceived — and I think there’s
some justification in that — of sort of standing back and saying, well, it’s really the institutions’
problem, the university should take care of this. But we’re the largest funder of biomedical
research in the world. We also have responsibilities to be sure that
the environment where that research is going on is free of this kind of immoral activity. So, we are now taking some ownership of this. And I wanted in that statement that was mentioned,
to make it very clear that we have not been as much of the solution as we should be. Sometimes, we have been part of the problem. We want to apologize for that. We have been listening to those stories — and
they’re harrowing stories — of women who have gone through these experiences. We don’t think that that’s something that
we can simply look the other way. So, we have decided, within the legal constrictions
that we have, to basically play a larger role in identifying instances and acting upon them. And in just the last year, more than two dozen
institutions have heard from us about circumstances where sexual harassment was going on, and
we have insisted that they come forward and say what they’re doing about it. As a result, some 21 disciplinary actions
have been taken against university faculty. Some have lost their jobs. Others have no longer been allowed to remain
as principal investigators on an NIH grant. Others are not allowed to take part in peer
review. We’re really serious about this. We’re not just saying it’s somebody else’s
problem. WILLIAM BRANGHAM: Many people are welcoming
of the statement that you put out, and they — and they feel that it’s heartfelt and earnest
and appreciate what you have said. But some people have pointed out that you’re
focusing a little bit too much on accountability once the crime has been committed, once harassment
has been identified, and not enough in changing a culture where this goes forward. In other words, they’re saying, do more on
the prevention side, not just the enforcement side. What’s your reaction to that? DR. FRANCIS COLLINS: I totally agree with that,
because it is not sufficient to simply try to address things once they have already happened. And that was a big part of the National Academy
recommendation, the need for culture change. We are, in fact, in constant communication
now with our institutions about the need for that. And, again, as we talked about earlier, a
lot of that is getting women in leadership positions, in the dean’s office, in the chairman’s
office, because that changes the culture in a way that this kind of gender harassment
simply becomes less acceptable. We’re going to promote that at every level
as we go through these next steps. And I agree, if all we do is address things
where there’s already been a bad action, we have not been sufficient. WILLIAM BRANGHAM: You have obviously spent
your entire career in the sciences. And I’m curious. When this started to bubble to the surface,
did this surprise you? Or was this something that you yourself had
seen as you came up in your own career? DR. FRANCIS COLLINS: I had seen, but I have to
be honest. As a male working in this male-dominated arena,
I had observed, but not personally taken responsibility for doing something about it at the level
that I now feel I should. One of the things that I hope comes out of
this very open public discussion now, where we have decided, yes, this is awkward, but
we’re going to talk about it, is that men will step up and take more responsibility
also for the change that’s needed. This shouldn’t just fall on the shoulders
of the women to fix the problem that the men have largely been responsible for. WILLIAM BRANGHAM: Dr. Francis Collins of the
National Institutes of Health, good luck with your work, and thank you for being here. DR. FRANCIS COLLINS: Thanks. It’s been great to be with you.